Cambodia's Muslims: More orthodox, less integrated
Milton Osborne / The Interpreter | 16 October 2014
The suggestion that members of Cambodia's Islamic minority have joined ISIS —a claim vigorously denied by leaders of this community — has briefly focused attention on a religious group in mainland Southeast Asia that is little understood by other than a few specialists.
The last time there was a similar flurry of media attention directed
towards Cambodia's Islamic community was when it was revealed that
Hambali (Riduan Isamuddin), the claimed mastermind behind the 2002 Bali
bombing, had been living in Cambodia for six months in late 2002 and
early 2003 before his arrest in August 2003 in Thailand. While details
remain obscure, it appears that Hambali received assistance while in
Cambodia from foreign Islamists—one Egyptian and two Thai. The extent to
which he dealt with the Cambodian Islamic community beyond living in a
small mosque in suburban Phnom Penh has never been established.
Even to write in terms of the Cambodian Islamic
'community' is misleading, or at very least inadequate. In the 1950s,
King Sihanouk, in an effort to find a way to emphasise that followers of
Islam were just as much part of the Cambodian nation as the majority
Buddhists, coined the term 'Khmers Islam' or 'Islamic Cambodians'.
Recently, I was told in Phnom Penh that this term is no longer in favour
among the followers of Islam themselves.
Moreover, its use, like the readiness to describe
the followers of Islam in Cambodia by their ethic identity as 'Chams',
is itself unsatisfactory (as an example, this misleading catch-all use
of the term Chams occurs in a 2010 Phnom Penh US Embassy cable released by Wikileaks).
Not all followers of Islam in Cambodia are, in fact, Chams, an ethnic
group originally from central Vietnam whose ancestors migrated to
Cambodia over many centuries. There are still a significant number of
Chams living in Vietnam itself.
Of the total number of members of the Islamic community, which may be
as many as 500,000 in a total population of 15 million, an uncertain
proportion, perhaps 10-15%, are Malays, the descendants of settlers from
sections of modern Malaysia and Sumatra. Moreover, there is an
important division within the Cham community between those who pray only
once a week and who regard themselves as the preservers of traditional
Cham culture, and those whose observance of Islam is more orthodox.
As already noted, detailed academic study of the Islamic community in
Cambodia in modern times has been limited, with the work by William
Collins of particular importance, though the reference I drew on for my
2004 Lowy Issues Brief, The 'Khmer Islam' Community in Cambodia and its Foreign Patrons no longer appears to be available on the web. Other more recent contributions include publications by Agnes de Feo and Alberto Perez.
The Legacy of the Khmer Rouge
The Islamic community suffered grievously during
the Pol Pot regime, with an estimated 95,000 dying from executions,
overwork, hunger and disease out of what was then a total population of
250,000. Mosques were destroyed, with some being used (with the
deliberate intention of causing grave offence) as pigsties, while
members of the community were forced to eat pork.
At the time the Pol Pot regime was overthrown, the
followers of Islam in Cambodia were in a shattered state. Their plight
was recognised, at first slowly, but later on a widespread basis, by
fellow Muslims in Southeast Asia and the Middle East, and funds began to
pour in to Cambodia to assist them. It is not an overstatement to note
that domestic and international reaction to the suffering the community
endured during the Khmer Rouge period has had a transformative effect on
Islam in Cambodia
The contemporary scene
The true scale of external aid to the Islamic community is almost
impossible to quantify. Individual donations are often reported in the
Cambodian press, with funds coming from the government of Saudi Arabia
and the Islamic Development Bank in Jeddah, for instance, as well as
from private individuals including in Dubai. But in the case of
Malaysia, there has been some reluctance to specify the size of the
largesse.
Equally, it is difficult to place precise numbers on the Islamic
'missionaries' who have come to Cambodia to preach a more orthodox
observance of Islam, in particular Dakwah Tabligh and Wahhabi Islam.
What is apparent is that there are now many more mosques, with new
mosques often built in a Middle Eastern architectural style, than was
the case before 1970. A range of reports refer to the adoption in many
Cambodian Muslim villages of stricter separation of the sexes in
communal gatherings and the wearing of Middle Eastern dress, including
women going fully veiled.
Equally uncertain is the precise number of
Cambodian followers of Islam studying abroad in southern Thailand,
Malaysia and the Middle East. The links with southern Thailand and
Malaysia go back as far as the nineteenth century, if not before. While
some foreign observers have questioned whether Cambodian Muslims have
participated in the endemic violence of southern Thailand, no convincing
evidence of such action has ever been presented.
Hun Sen's CPP government has repeatedly claimed that
it is both comfortable in its dealings with the Islamic community and
alert to any suggestions that members of the community might be
vulnerable to extremist teachings. The mufti of
Cambodia's Islamic community operates with government approval, but more
importantly leading members of the community have held important
offices during the CPP's long tenure in office (eg. figures such as Mat
Ly and Ahmad Yahya, the first after a period of working with the Khmer
Rouge, the latter as secretary for social affairs and as a translator of
the Koran into the Cham language).
As a long-time observer of Cambodia, I have been struck during recent
visits to Phnom Penh by the extent to which, in the eyes of my ethnic
Cambodian interlocutors, the Islamic community is seen as firmly apart
from the Buddhist majority, however much the Government seeks to present
a picture of 'Khmers Islam' as an integral part of the nation. These
views come from a limited and admittedly elite sample of local
observers. But one theme was pervasive: the belief that the Islamic
community in Cambodia is more rather than less integrated into the
national community than once was the case.
It has long been the case that many Muslim villages have existed as
separate entities, and the suggestion is that this separation has been
reinforced in villages located along the Mekong and Tonle Sap Rivers as a
result of the growth of orthodox Islam. The tendency for followers of
Islam in Cambodia living in distinctly separate villages is, according
to some observers, less marked among Malay members of the community.
On one point there seemed to be general agreement among those I have
spoken to over recent years: the extent to which the majority of the
Islamic community remains poor and lacking in modern education. Whether
this makes members of the community more vulnerable to extremist
blandishments is an open question.
Photo courtesy of Flickr user Edwin Lee.
No comments:
Post a Comment